Register / Log in

View Classic Site
Latest News
Merlin (mini-series)
The New 'The 3 Film Collection' Gathers the '98 Miniseries and Both Sequels!
Magical Legend of the Leprechauns, The (mini-series)
The 1999 Mini-Series is Getting a Re-Release, This Time with Digital Copy
Miami Vice
Mill Creek's 'Crime Time TV' DVD Set Combines 'Vice,' 'Knight Rider,' and More!
10th Kingdom, The (mini-series)
New Blu-ray and DVD Release of the Mini-Series Will Include Digital Copies!
Walking Dead, The
Early Cover Art Shuffles In for 'The Complete 8th Season'
more news
Pick of the Week
Latest Review

The Complete 8th Season

The Complete 1st Season

Doctor Who - What's With the Commentary Track on Season 3 Being Replaced?

There's the BBC's Official Statement...and then Fans take it From There

Posted by David Lambert
Doctor Who - The Complete 3rd Series, released on DVD earlier this month in North America, was quickly noticed to have an issue with the final episode on the set, "Last of the Time Lords" (the last part of a 3-part story) having a "wrong commentary track." The booklet and the pre-release materials indicated that David Tennant ("The Doctor"), Freema Agyeman ("Martha Jones") and John Barrowman ("Capt. Jack Harkness") recorded a commentary track for the DVD release of this episode. However, fans only found a re-run of the internet podcast by the show's Producers. We've been trying to dig into this with the BBC, and the only on-the-record response given was this statement by a BBC Worldwide spokesperson:
    From BBC Worldwide
    "Unfortunately, though we make every effort to offer identical content in our Doctor Who releases to every territory, the original commentary track for Series 3, Episode 13 featuring David Tennant, Freema Agyeman and John Barrowman could not be cleared for the North American DVD. We acknowledge that the booklet accompanying it has the incorrect credits and they should read Russell T Davies, Julie Gardner and Phil Collinson. The booklet will be corrected as soon as possible."
"Could not be cleared"...the message boards all over the 'net are speculating on what this means. The consensus is...singing. Folks who have access to the U.K. release know that there is singing on the commentary track, led by Barrowman, and everyone figures that the rights to the different songs (there are more than one) were unable to be cleared for use outside of the United Kingdom. Is that accurate? The BBC won't say for sure on the record, so we'll just have to leave you hanging right there...sorry. If true, though, I think we can expect a "no singing" policy to be instituted pronto for future commentary track recordings!

Doctor Who - The Complete 3rd Series large box art

Twitter Graphic

Link to this page:
All news for this show:
More info on this show:
Doctor Who

Copyright 2001-2018
CBS Interactive
Contact us - Sitemap - Privacy Policy - Terms of Use
A CBS Interactive Site